Marco Island
   Account Login   |   Register Marco Island Homes | Marco Island Real Estate - TenneyTeam.com
 
Search By Property Address

 
 
(List Sorted by Numerical Address)
 
 
What are you looking for in a home?
 
 

Select Property Type (Location)
 
 
Select Price Range
To

 
 
Select Year Built Range
To

Minimum Number of Bedrooms


Minimum Number of Bathrooms

 
 
Select Sqft Range
To
 
 
Private Pool?
 
 
Minimum Garage Size:

 
   

REAL ESTATE MARKET: Closed Sales Analysis
Based on your property search we found a total of 203 Marco Island homes have SOLD in the last 6 months
Average Sale Price: $965,197
Average SQFT of Homes Sold: 2,442 Sqft
Average Price Per SQFT: $395 / Sqft*

*Please Note: The average price per sqft does not reflect any land value adjustments
513 5th Ave 513 5th Ave Marco Island Florida
List Price: $370,500

MLS Number: 2191986
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Center Island North - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,120 sqft
1,462 sqft
1972
Yes
No
1


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Shingle
Unfurnished
South
None
No
$2195





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1180 Sunbird Ave 2 / 2 1248 Y 1971 $365000 2019-10-04 $356040
1161 Collier N Blvd 3 / 2 1675 Y 1973 $405000 2019-10-01 $366150
206 Majorca Cir 2 / 2 1377 Y 1969 $375000 2019-08-01 $357010
1260 Skylark Ave 3 / 1 1158 Y 1970 $335000 2019-05-24 $332340
469 Yellowbird St 2 / 2 1166 N 1972 $305000 2019-04-15 $341780
106 Greenbrier St 3 / 2 1296 N 1967 $448900 2019-03-20 $476580
*Estimated Market Value: $371,650
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Marco

281 2nd Ave 281 2nd Ave Marco Island Florida
List Price: $398,000

MLS Number: 2191947
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Highlands - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
2
2
1,894 sqft
2,304 sqft
2004
No
No
2


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
1
0
Shingle
Unfurnished
South
None
No
$3892





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
341 Worthington St 3 / 2 1700 Y 2000 $450000 2019-08-19 $437160
2055 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1679 Y 2002 $430000 2019-08-09 $420100
2023 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1981 Y 2002 $460000 2019-08-05 $407820
1813 Bahama Ave 3 / 2 1729 N 2001 $400000 2019-07-19 $423100
261 Bald Eagle Dr 3 / 2 1521 Y 2001 $458000 2019-05-28 $470220
1171 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1870 Y 2003 $480000 2019-04-18 $443360
*Estimated Market Value: $433,627
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Premier Sotheby`s International Realty

1520 Honeysuckle Ave 1520 Honeysuckle Ave Marco Island Florida
List Price: $399,900

MLS Number: 2192303
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Center Island South - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,746 sqft
2,126 sqft
1999
No
No
2


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Shingle
Unfurnished
North
None
No
$2091





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1440 Galleon Ave 3 / 2 1814 Y 1996 $430000 2019-08-30 $383200
341 Worthington St 3 / 2 1700 Y 2000 $450000 2019-08-19 $416440
2055 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1679 Y 2002 $430000 2019-08-09 $399380
2023 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1981 Y 2002 $460000 2019-08-05 $387100
1813 Bahama Ave 3 / 2 1729 N 2001 $400000 2019-07-19 $402380
119 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1485 N 1996 $380000 2019-07-02 $406100
299 Heathwood S Dr 3 / 2 1502 Y 1996 $495000 2019-05-28 $479400
261 Bald Eagle Dr 3 / 2 1521 Y 2001 $458000 2019-05-28 $449500
1170 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1368 Y 1996 $435000 2019-04-23 $432800
1171 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1870 Y 2003 $480000 2019-04-18 $422640
163 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1732 Y 1998 $440000 2019-04-17 $401400
*Estimated Market Value: $416,395
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Gulf Coast Realty

2043 San Marco Rd 2043 San Marco Rd Marco Island Florida
List Price: $410,000

MLS Number: 2191876
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Island East - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
2
2
1,353 sqft
2,048 sqft
1997
Yes
No
2


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Shingle
Unfurnished
Southwest
None
No
$3332





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1440 Galleon Ave 3 / 2 1814 Y 1996 $430000 2019-08-30 $383900
341 Worthington St 3 / 2 1700 Y 2000 $450000 2019-08-19 $401420
2055 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1679 Y 2002 $430000 2019-08-09 $384360
2023 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1981 Y 2002 $460000 2019-08-05 $372080
1813 Bahama Ave 3 / 2 1729 N 2001 $400000 2019-07-19 $387360
119 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1485 N 1996 $380000 2019-07-02 $406800
299 Heathwood S Dr 3 / 2 1502 Y 1996 $495000 2019-05-28 $480100
261 Bald Eagle Dr 3 / 2 1521 Y 2001 $458000 2019-05-28 $434480
1170 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1368 Y 1996 $435000 2019-04-23 $433500
1171 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1870 Y 2003 $480000 2019-04-18 $407620
165 Leland Way 4 / 2 1789 N 1994 $445000 2019-04-18 $441400
163 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1732 Y 1998 $440000 2019-04-17 $402100
*Estimated Market Value: $411,260
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Re/max Affinity Plus

373 3rd Ave 373 3rd Ave Marco Island Florida
List Price: $425,000

MLS Number: 2191040
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Highlands - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,848 sqft
3,264 sqft
1984
No
No
0


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
1
Metal
Negotiable
South
None
No
$907





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
297 Capistrano Ct 3 / 2 1632 Y 1990 $500000 2019-09-30 $481600
184 Balfour Dr 4 / 4 2477 Y 1989 $465000 2019-09-17 $377825
806 Amber Dr 3 / 2 1212 Y 1978 $510000 2019-09-10 $514520
2060 Dogwood Dr 3 / 2 1862 Y 1991 $432000 2019-08-30 $390600
100 Sand Hill St 3 / 2 1723 N 1989 $350000 2019-08-19 $359375
2030 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1984 Y 1984 $455000 2019-08-14 $404800
2003 Sheffield Ave 3 / 3 2663 Y 1989 $485000 2019-08-02 $383875
1021 Valley Ave 3 / 2 1598 Y 1987 $510000 2019-06-10 $488750
351 Yellowbird St 3 / 2 1622 Y 1991 $362000 2019-06-03 $344600
108 Landmark St 3 / 2 1818 Y 1978 $408000 2019-05-28 $370100
1996 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1448 N 1985 $340000 2019-05-16 $370000
101 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1348 Y 1986 $445000 2019-05-14 $442500
632 Seagrape Dr 2 / 2 1242 Y 1978 $460000 2019-05-13 $462420
101 Beachcomber St 2 / 2 1289 N 1982 $400000 2019-05-02 $441925
360 Bali Ct 3 / 2 1884 Y 1978 $390000 2019-04-30 $347480
474 Yellowbird St 3 / 2 1807 N 1983 $330000 2019-04-30 $333075
65 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1423 N 1989 $350000 2019-04-18 $381875
2040 Sheffield Ave 4 / 3 2186 N 1983 $406000 2019-04-02 $380650
1216 Bluebird Ave 2 / 2 1488 Y 1978 $370000 2019-03-28 $355200
*Estimated Market Value: $401,641
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Horizons By The Sea; Inc

1274 Jamaica Rd 1274 Jamaica Rd Marco Island Florida
List Price: $425,000

MLS Number: 2170754
Property Type: Golf Course Home
Island Location: Center Island South - Search Golf Course Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,256 sqft
1,553 sqft
1969
No
No
1


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Tile
Unfurnished
North
None
No
$1537





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1266 Jamaica Rd 3 / 2 1720 Y 1968 $515000 2019-07-29 $442520
284 Shadowridge Ct 3 / 2 1795 Y 1968 $425000 2019-07-22 $347270
553 Yellowbird St 3 / 2 1791 N 1969 $475000 2019-06-12 $437550
1217 Fruitland Ave 3 / 2 1783 N 1967 $435000 2019-05-15 $398110
*Estimated Market Value: $406,363
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Co.

1369 Merrimac Ave 1369 Merrimac Ave Marco Island Florida
List Price: $445,000

MLS Number: 2180436
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Center Island North - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,378 sqft
1,711 sqft
1988
Yes
No
2


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Shingle
Unfurnished
South
None
No
$2923





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
297 Capistrano Ct 3 / 2 1632 Y 1990 $500000 2019-09-30 $474600
940 Ironwood Ct 3 / 2 1379 Y 1987 $555000 2019-09-05 $554925
2060 Dogwood Dr 3 / 2 1862 Y 1991 $432000 2019-08-30 $383600
100 Sand Hill St 3 / 2 1723 N 1989 $350000 2019-08-19 $364125
2030 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1984 Y 1984 $455000 2019-08-14 $409550
1021 Valley Ave 3 / 2 1598 Y 1987 $510000 2019-06-10 $493500
351 Yellowbird St 3 / 2 1622 Y 1991 $362000 2019-06-03 $337600
1996 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1448 N 1985 $340000 2019-05-16 $374750
101 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1348 Y 1986 $445000 2019-05-14 $447250
101 Beachcomber St 2 / 2 1289 N 1982 $400000 2019-05-02 $446675
65 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1423 N 1989 $350000 2019-04-18 $386625
165 Leland Way 4 / 2 1789 N 1994 $445000 2019-04-18 $443900
*Estimated Market Value: $426,425
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Engel And Volkers Marco Island

9 Tahiti Rd 9 Tahiti Rd Marco Island Florida
List Price: $449,000

MLS Number: 2192129
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Center Island North - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,853 sqft
3,000 sqft
1984
Yes
No
2


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
1
0
Metal See Remarks
Partially Furnished
Southeast
None
No
$2382





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
297 Capistrano Ct 3 / 2 1632 Y 1990 $500000 2019-09-30 $522100
184 Balfour Dr 4 / 4 2477 Y 1989 $465000 2019-09-17 $418200
806 Amber Dr 3 / 2 1212 Y 1978 $510000 2019-09-10 $554870
940 Ironwood Ct 3 / 2 1379 Y 1987 $555000 2019-09-05 $590550
2060 Dogwood Dr 3 / 2 1862 Y 1991 $432000 2019-08-30 $431100
100 Sand Hill St 3 / 2 1723 N 1989 $350000 2019-08-19 $399750
2030 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1984 Y 1984 $455000 2019-08-14 $445175
2003 Sheffield Ave 3 / 3 2663 Y 1989 $485000 2019-08-02 $424250
1021 Valley Ave 3 / 2 1598 Y 1987 $510000 2019-06-10 $529125
351 Yellowbird St 3 / 2 1622 Y 1991 $362000 2019-06-03 $385100
108 Landmark St 3 / 2 1818 Y 1978 $408000 2019-05-28 $410450
1996 Sheffield Ave 3 / 2 1448 N 1985 $340000 2019-05-16 $410375
101 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1348 Y 1986 $445000 2019-05-14 $482875
632 Seagrape Dr 2 / 2 1242 Y 1978 $460000 2019-05-13 $502770
101 Beachcomber St 2 / 2 1289 N 1982 $400000 2019-05-02 $482300
360 Bali Ct 3 / 2 1884 Y 1978 $390000 2019-04-30 $387830
65 Tahiti Rd 3 / 2 1423 N 1989 $350000 2019-04-18 $422250
2040 Sheffield Ave 4 / 3 2186 N 1983 $406000 2019-04-02 $421025
350 Worthington St 3 / 3 1634 Y 1978 $535000 2019-04-01 $550330
1216 Bluebird Ave 2 / 2 1488 Y 1978 $370000 2019-03-28 $395550
*Estimated Market Value: $458,299
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Independent Brokers Realty

810 Apple Ct 810 Apple Ct Marco Island Florida
List Price: $449,900

MLS Number: 2190810
Property Type: Water Indirect Home
Island Location: River - Search Water Indirect Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,424 sqft
1,737 sqft
1969
No
No
1


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Metal
Unfurnished
Southwest
80 Ft
Yes
$4772





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1139 Mulberry Ct 3 / 2 1418 Y 1973 $500000 2019-08-15 $460360
84 Buttercup Ct 3 / 2 1296 Y 1968 $405000 2019-07-01 $372680
1240 Collier N Blvd 3 / 2 1142 N 1968 $392000 2019-06-11 $408920
820 Willow Ct 2 / 2 1769 Y 1967 $525000 2019-04-16 $464300
*Estimated Market Value: $426,565
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Res. Re Inc

238 Tahiti Rd 238 Tahiti Rd Marco Island Florida
List Price: $449,900

MLS Number: 2190811
Property Type: Inland Home
Island Location: Center Island North - Search Inland Homes In This Area of the Island

Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
AC Sqft:
Total Sqft:
Year Built:
Private Pool:
Spa:
Garage Space:
Special Info:
3
2
1,269 sqft
1,618 sqft
1998
Yes
No
3


  Den:
Half Baths:
Roof Type:
Furnished:
Rear Exposure:
Waterfront Available:
Dock Space:
Real Estate Taxes:
0
0
Shingle
Furnished
Southwest
None
No
$3135





Click on each image below to view larger photo

Closed Sales Comparables

The closed sales provided below, are not intended to represent a true market value for this home.
No market value adjustments have been made for properties that are renovated or updated or based on island location, lot size or views.

If you wish to discuss this property in more details, please give us a call.


Address Bed/Bath Sqft Pool Year Sale Price Sale Date Adj Value
1500 Biscayne Way 3 / 2 1902 Y 2003 $560000 2019-10-04 $471380
1440 Galleon Ave 3 / 2 1814 Y 1996 $430000 2019-08-30 $375500
274 Sand Hill St 3 / 2 1718 Y 2001 $560000 2019-08-27 $497140
341 Worthington St 3 / 2 1700 Y 2000 $450000 2019-08-19 $389660
2055 San Marco Rd 3 / 2 1679 Y 2002 $430000 2019-08-09 $372600
1813 Bahama Ave 3 / 2 1729 N 2001 $400000 2019-07-19 $375600
119 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1485 N 1996 $380000 2019-07-02 $398400
1760 Granada Dr 3 / 2 1628 Y 1999 $530000 2019-06-03 $494100
299 Heathwood S Dr 3 / 2 1502 Y 1996 $495000 2019-05-28 $471700
261 Bald Eagle Dr 3 / 2 1521 Y 2001 $458000 2019-05-28 $422720
1170 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1368 Y 1996 $435000 2019-04-23 $425100
112 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1796 Y 2001 $525000 2019-04-18 $451220
1171 Bluebird Ave 3 / 2 1870 Y 2003 $480000 2019-04-18 $395860
165 Leland Way 4 / 2 1789 N 1994 $445000 2019-04-18 $433000
163 Cyrus St 3 / 2 1732 Y 1998 $440000 2019-04-17 $393700
*Estimated Market Value: $424,512
MLS IDX
Real Estate Listing is Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Res. Re Inc

FIRST PREV NEXT 10 PROPERTIES | LAST
Copyright & Data Information Disclosure
The data source of real property information is the copyrighted / proprietary database compilation of Marco Multi/List, Inc. All rights reserved. ęCopyright 2018 Marco Multi/List, Inc.
PLEASE NOTE: The accuracy of this information provided is not warranted or guaranteed. The information should be independently verified if any person intends to engage in a transaction in reliance upon it.